'Don't let the seeds of hatred and distrust be planted': Education Minister responds to unhappiness over school lessons on Israel-Hamas conflict

SINGAPORE — The character and citizenship education (CCE) lessons conducted in schools on the Israel-Hamas conflict aim to help students process their emotions and information about the issue, and are not meant to be history lessons or to ascribe blame, said Education Minister Chan Chun Sing.

Given Singapore's social fabric and the deluge of information on the issue, it was all the more urgent to have frank discussions with students to help them understand the complex topic, he added.

He also thanked educators for their professionalism, noting that they too had their own personal feelings and convictions about the issue, but had not imposed them on students.

His comments, during an interview on Feb 25 with SPH Media and Mediacorp, came amid concerns from some parents about the CCE materials. They had put up social media posts expressing their unhappiness with the lesson content and how their children were taught about the conflict, accusing the Ministry of Education (MOE) of taking sides, among other criticisms.

Chan said MOE had foreseen the challenges in dealing with such a complex topic.

"Whether it is this issue or the Russia-Ukraine conflict, whenever it comes to CCE, we fully expect that there will be issues that will elicit different reactions from different people," he said.

"It can be a manner of degree, it can be in different ways. So I think we are mentally prepared for this."

Despite the challenges involved in teaching the topic, when MOE came together with principals and teachers, they had all agreed upon a common objective to "build a shared ethos of how we respond as Singaporeans", he added.

Chan noted that the lessons are not meant to be history lessons and are also not an exercise to apportion blame to one party or another.

In fact, CCE lessons, which typically include discussions on a range of contemporary issues and global events, aim to achieve four things.

First, to help students understand their own emotions and empathise with others; second, to reflect on how to safeguard cohesion and harmony in a multiracial society; third, to learn to verify information sources before sharing them responsibly; and fourth, to appreciate the diversity of views and conduct conversations sensitively and respectfully. 

While not easily achieved, the alternative would be to leave students to grapple with the issue on their own and be subject to external influences, or worse, be misguided by biased sources on social media, said Chan.

Already, students and Singaporeans in general have been flooded with unverified information, images and misinformation being circulated online, he said.

This has stirred emotions on an issue that many Singaporeans feel strongly about, and sometimes sparked heated conversation, including among young people, he noted.

[[nid:660617]]

"So, we have to be very careful not to let the seeds of hatred and distrust be planted in our younger generations," he said.

"We must understand Singapore's vulnerabilities and interests, and work hard to preserve our cohesion, mutual tolerance and acceptance, and find ways to preserve our multiracial and multi-religious harmony.

Against this backdrop, the CCE lessons are meant to create a safe environment for students to understand what is happening in the world around them, he added.

He said MOE had worked with other ministries and agencies, like the Ministry of Foreign Affairs, to curate age-appropriate materials for students to help them understand the conflict.

It also discussed the material with professional educators and principals.

On the concerns some parents have raised — such as on the teaching material — Chan said the CCE lessons would be updated based on new developments and information.

The first tranche of materials was updated till December 2023, and MOE will continue to update it every two to three months, he added.

"So, we update the curriculum in tranches because as we speak, new developments are happening," he said.

On a particular slide in the CCE lessons that was posted online on the events of Oct 7, when Hamas attacked Israel and Israel retaliated, Chan said it should not be taken in isolation.

He added that there are also slides that recount the complex and violent history behind the conflict for teachers' reference, and materials that go even further back to encourage older students to read and understand this conflict in detail.

The war in Gaza erupted after Hamas militants crossed the border into Israel on Oct 7, killing 1,200 Israelis and taking 240 people as hostages in a brutal rampage through Israeli towns.

Since then, the Israeli retaliation in Gaza has laid much of the enclave to waste, sending the Palestinian death toll surging to almost 30,000, according to Gaza's Health Ministry.

"Some people may have mischaracterised it and say that we only present from Oct 7 and beyond. Our position is very clear. This is a conflict with a long history, many things have happened," he said.

He added that Singapore has joined many countries in the United Nations to call for a ceasefire and humanitarian support for the victims, and has always supported a two-state solution.

Besides updating the teaching materials, MOE will also evolve its teaching methods, taking in feedback from stakeholders, he said.

On whether the ministry would consider an opt-out option for parents who do not feel comfortable letting their children participate in this CCE lesson, Mr Chan said it was important to look at the purpose of CCE lessons, which is to promote mutual understanding and social harmony.

"I think we want all our students to be able to appreciate this," he said.

"If we approach it from this perspective, then we can understand the importance of inculcating such values to our students... how we work together with people from diverse backgrounds to promote our social harmony and cohesion, how we work together to verify facts, how we work together such that at the end of the day, even if we hold different perspectives, we can have a respectful conversation."

At the end of the day, this is not issue- or conflict-specific, Chan noted, adding that these values are important in Singapore's multiracial and multi-religious society.

Principals, teachers play a key role

[[nid:671083]]

Chan was also asked about teachers who may feel strongly on the issue, and he said they had carried out their duties with professionalism.

"They do not impose their personal views on our students. As professionals, they are committed to guide our children to the best of their abilities to understand the importance of upholding our social harmony, verifying information as a life skill, and appreciating diverse perspectives respectfully," he said.

He added that the CCE lessons were prepared in consultation with educators, and that school leaders helped to prepare and select teachers to teach the material and facilitate the discussions.

"I must credit our educators for the conviction and courage to do this well, despite the challenges, for the sake of our children and our people," he said.

Chan was also asked how he would address the concerns of teachers who feel conflicted about the lessons.

He said: "We understand that different teachers may have their individual concerns, and this is not just about the Malay/Muslim community. It can also apply to the Jewish community, the Christian communities, or any other people of different faiths, or from different backgrounds.

"We make it a point to make sure that we help the schools to form the teams to deliver (the lessons) as a team, rather than as individuals."

ALSO READ: Threat against Singapore increases since Israel-Hamas war began, including rocket and bomb threats: Shanmugam

This article was first published in The Straits Times. Permission required for reproduction.

Disclaimer: The copyright of this article belongs to the original author. Reposting this article is solely for the purpose of information dissemination and does not constitute any investment advice. If there is any infringement, please contact us immediately. We will make corrections or deletions as necessary. Thank you.